Plan your stop
Useful details
The official rooms policy states that pets are not allowed. Confirm room type, swimming or kayak access, minimum stays, deposits, accessibility and cancellation terms.
Available public information reports a no-pets policy. Service-animal access may be governed separately; confirm directly.
On Cudjoe & Sugarloaf Keys, at MM 17–23
Sugarloaf Lodge sits in Cudjoe & Sugarloaf Keys (Lower Keys, MM 17–23). Wide-open Lower Keys scenery, boat access, RV stays and a slower pace before Key West. This listing is for choosing a pillow that matches the mile marker, parking and the rest of the day’s water or walking plans.
Other hotels & lodging listings currently published on Cudjoe & Sugarloaf Keys include Sugarloaf Key Hotel at KOA Resort. Compare them on the island or category hub rather than assuming this pin is the only option.
What this record includes
- Directory category
- Hotels & Lodging
- Island area
- Cudjoe & Sugarloaf Keys (Lower Keys, MM 17–23)
- Mapped as
- hotels & lodging
- Published address
- 17001 Overseas Hwy, Sugarloaf Key, FL 33042
- Published phone
- 305-745-3211
- Official website on file
- Yes — confirm details there
- Mapped or source amenities
- 31 waterfront rooms, Private patios or balconies, Free Wi-Fi and parking, Swimming and kayaking access, Adjacent marina, Onsite restaurant
- Source
- Sugarloaf Lodge official website
Confirm before you go
- Current hours, closures, fees and access rules on the linked source
- Whether the location is public, customer-only, resident-only or temporarily closed
- Today’s hours — this directory does not invent opening times
- Parking, pet, trailer and fee rules with the property
- No ratings or “best of” rank — KeysCompass does not invent scores
How to use this listing
Sugarloaf Lodge is mapped as lodging in Cudjoe & Sugarloaf Keys (Lower Keys, MM 17–23). A Keys mailing address can sit well away from the marina, park or Old Town block you think you booked.
Compare the island and mile marker before the room rate. Confirm parking, resort fees, trailer or dock rules and pet policy with the property. KeysCompass does not sell organic lodging rank, and this page is not a booking engine.
Listed amenities & features
- 31 waterfront rooms
- Private patios or balconies
- Free Wi-Fi and parking
- Swimming and kayaking access
- Adjacent marina
- Onsite restaurant
This listing was reviewed using Sugarloaf Lodge official website. The official website is the right place for menus, rates, reservations and hours. Directory text is a planning aid, not a live operations feed. Last reviewed on Jul 28, 2026 using Sugarloaf Lodge official website.
Business owner or traveler? Report an update →Claim or feature this listing →Featured placements are labeled sponsorships. They do not buy organic directory rank.