KeysCompassMy trip 0

Hotels & Lodging · Islamorada

Amara Cay Resort

Boutique resort in Islamorada with views toward Alligator Reef Lighthouse, a beach, a pool, a poolside Tiki Bar and ReelCatch restaurant. Rooms and suites have balconies or lanais, and guests can use the restaurants and amenities at sister resorts La Siesta and Three Waters, linked by a resort water taxi.

Visit official website ↗Open map ↗

Plan your stop

Useful details

On Islamorada, at MM 72–90

Amara Cay Resort sits in Islamorada (Upper Keys, MM 72–90). A six-island village with sportfishing, galleries, waterfront restaurants and family attractions. This listing is for choosing a pillow that matches the mile marker, parking and the rest of the day’s water or walking plans.

Other hotels & lodging listings currently published on Islamorada include La Siesta Resort & Villas, Key Lantern Motel & Blue Fin Inn, Three Waters Resort and Marina, Islamorada, a Tribute Portfolio Resort. Compare them on the island or category hub rather than assuming this listing is the only option.

What this record includes

Directory category
Hotels & Lodging
Island area
Islamorada (Upper Keys, MM 72–90)
Mapped as
hotel or similar lodging
Published address
80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Published phone
+1 888 317 0889
Official website on file
Yes — confirm details there
Mapped or source amenities
Wheelchair accessible, Wi-Fi
Wheelchair tag
yes
Coordinates
24.899985, -80.655169
Source
Islamorada Resort Collection — Amara Cay Resort

Confirm before you go

  • Current hours, closures, fees and access rules on the linked source
  • Today’s hours — none are published on this listing
  • Parking, pet, trailer and fee rules with the property
  • Anything the map source does not tag — a map is not a live business profile
  • No ratings or “best of” rank — this page does not score or rank places

How to use this listing

Amara Cay Resort is mapped as lodging in Islamorada (Upper Keys, MM 72–90). A Keys mailing address can sit well away from the marina, park or Old Town block you think you booked.

Compare the island and mile marker before the room rate. Confirm parking, resort fees, trailer or dock rules and pet policy with the property. The order of lodging listings is not for sale, and this page is not a booking engine.

Listed amenities & features

  • Wheelchair accessible
  • Wi-Fi
Use this listing withIslamorada island directoryHotels & Lodging across the KeysAdd this stop to a trip listWhere to stay by Key
Source & accuracy

Amara Cay Resort is published from public map contributors. Mapped names, coordinates and tags can lag real-world changes. Empty fields stay empty: this page adds no reviews, phones, hours, prices or ratings that the map does not have. Use the linked map object and any official site to confirm before a special trip. Last reviewed on Oct 28, 2026 using Islamorada Resort Collection — Amara Cay Resort.

Business owner or traveler? Report an update →Claim or correct this listing