Plan your stop
Useful details
Phone +1-305-745-3549 is the hotel line on the operator dining page, not a separately published café desk. This café is separate from sugarloaf-key-hotel-koa-resort and sugarloaf-key-key-west-koa-resort. Confirm current meal service on https://www.sugarloafkeyhotel.com/dining.
Before you choose a meal
Current menu and hours
Menus, daily specials, prices and kitchen hours can change. Use the official business website to check today’s details before making a special trip.
Check menu & current hours ↗On Cudjoe & Sugarloaf Keys, at MM 17–23
The Cafe at Sugarloaf KOA sits in Cudjoe & Sugarloaf Keys (Lower Keys, MM 17–23). Wide-open Lower Keys scenery, boat access, RV stays and a slower pace before Key West. This listing is for a meal that fits the route instead of an extra hour on U.S. 1.
Other restaurants & nightlife listings currently published on Cudjoe & Sugarloaf Keys include The Pub at Sugarloaf KOA. Compare them on the island or category hub rather than assuming this listing is the only option.
What this record includes
- Directory category
- Restaurants & Nightlife
- Island area
- Cudjoe & Sugarloaf Keys (Lower Keys, MM 17–23)
- Mapped as
- restaurants & nightlife
- Published address
- 251 State Road 939, Sugarloaf Key, FL 33042
- Published phone
- +1-305-745-3549
- Official website on file
- Yes — confirm details there
- Cuisine tags
- Italian & Pizza, Breakfast & Brunch, Fast Food & Casual
- Mapped or source amenities
- Breakfast, Sandwiches, Pizza
- Source
- Sugarloaf Key Hotel official dining page
Confirm before you go
- Current hours, closures, fees and access rules on the linked source
- Today’s hours — none are published on this listing
- Menu, kitchen hours and seating policy for the meal you actually want
- No ratings or “best of” rank — this page does not score or rank places
How to use this listing
The Cafe at Sugarloaf KOA is a food-and-drink listing in Cudjoe & Sugarloaf Keys (Lower Keys, MM 17–23). Use it to decide whether the stop sits on today’s stretch of U.S. 1—not as a substitute for today’s menu or kitchen hours.
Open the source link for current service. Sunset and weekend windows fill; a flexible lunch is often the easier waterfront meal. Dog rules, if any, belong to the patio or property, not to a directory badge alone.
Listed amenities & features
- Breakfast
- Sandwiches
- Pizza
This listing was reviewed using Sugarloaf Key Hotel official dining page. The official website is the right place for menus, rates, reservations and hours. Directory text is a planning aid, not a live operations feed. Last reviewed on Oct 7, 2026 using Sugarloaf Key Hotel official dining page.
Business owner or traveler? Report an update →Claim or correct this listing