Plan your stop
Useful details
Confirm current opening hours, menu, weekly specials, ordering options, seating and accessibility before visiting.
On Summerland Key, at MM 24–25
A Slice of Paradise sits in Summerland Key (Lower Keys, MM 24–25). A laid-back island stop with a small airfield, marina services and local food. This listing is for a meal that fits the route instead of an extra hour on U.S. 1.
Other restaurants & nightlife listings currently published on Summerland Key include Five Brothers Two. Compare them on the island or category hub rather than assuming this listing is the only option.
What this record includes
- Directory category
- Restaurants & Nightlife
- Island area
- Summerland Key (Lower Keys, MM 24–25)
- Mapped as
- restaurants & nightlife
- Published address
- 24458 Overseas Hwy, Summerland Key, FL 33042
- Published phone
- 305-744-9718
- Cuisine tags
- American & Keys Classics, Italian & Pizza
- Mapped or source amenities
- Hand-tossed pizza, Specialty pies, Hot subs and wings, Salads and calzones, Casual takeout
- Source
- Official Florida Keys tourism directory
Confirm before you go
- Current hours, closures, fees and access rules on the linked source
- Today’s hours — none are published on this listing
- Menu, kitchen hours and seating policy for the meal you actually want
- No ratings or “best of” rank — this page does not score or rank places
How to use this listing
A Slice of Paradise is a food-and-drink listing in Summerland Key (Lower Keys, MM 24–25). Use it to decide whether the stop sits on today’s stretch of U.S. 1—not as a substitute for today’s menu or kitchen hours.
Open the source link for current service. Sunset and weekend windows fill; a flexible lunch is often the easier waterfront meal. Dog rules, if any, belong to the patio or property, not to a directory badge alone.
Listed amenities & features
- Hand-tossed pizza
- Specialty pies
- Hot subs and wings
- Salads and calzones
- Casual takeout
This listing was reviewed using Official Florida Keys tourism directory. Hours, prices, access and availability can change. Confirm directly before making a special trip. Last reviewed on Jul 21, 2026 using Official Florida Keys tourism directory.
Business owner or traveler? Report an update →Claim or correct this listing